I can’t believe you get called up every year! I only got summoned for jury duty once about 10 years ago. I had to call in every so often to see if they had a case for me to serve on but I never had to actually show up during the whole time I was on call.
Jury Duty Dilemma
Posted by Lisa Hendey in News on Tuesday, June 28, 2011 1:00 PM
It happens about once a year - I stroll out to the mailbox suspecting nothing but the latest bills and ads and am greeted by a simple teal letter: my summons for jury duty. It always seems to come at the most inconvenient times, when taking hours to head downtown and sit in a room waiting feels like an awful fate. But the truth is, there is never a more convenient time and once I get there, I typically enjoy the experience.
The first time I ever served jury duty, I was a young professional woman working in Los Angeles. During a two week stint, I served on a criminal jury related to a solicitation of murder trial and a civil jury related to an accident. In those days, jury duty was a relaxing break from the hectic corporate environment and was actually a fascinating experience, a peek into our criminal justice system.
For several years when my children were little, I dodged summons with the “I’m a stay at home mom” excuse. About five years ago, I began to accept my annual fate. At that time, it became clear to me in watching my fellow jurors that “stay at home mom” was in the eyes of the court no longer a valid reason not to serve. Moms who tried to be excused were told that they needed to make arrangements with relatives and that they could defer their service for up to six months, but that they would be required to serve nonetheless. I have wondered to myself how women with no support system could possibly be expected to suddenly find care for little ones, but it seems that my state (or at least the county where I live) doesn’t consider this their problem to solve.
So this week, I wait. The system has been refined and I am “on call”, dialing in at the end of each day to learn my fate. I am hoping that my number will not be called, but if I am required to serve, I will rearrange my schedule and do my duty. I have a family member who strongly believes that juries should be comprised of professionals who are paid to render informed decisions. I respectfully disagree, and my annual interaction with the jury system has shown me that most of my fellow jurors seem to take their civic duties seriously.
How about you? Have you served jury duty? Does your state allow exemptions for moms? What have you learned from serving? Do you consider jury duty service to be a form of community service and a responsibility of faith-filled Catholics?
Comments
Page 1 of 1 pages
In New Jersey we are called once every 3 years—at most. It can be less frequent than that. I recently served, since my youngest is 9 and I had older kids home to care for him after school; wrote about it here: http://sfomom.blogspot.com/2011/06/impartial.html
I’m glad I served, much as I was relieved not to be assigned that case. I do consider it my duty as a citizen—just like voting, but more inconvenient. Think of the inconveniences that deployed soldiers and their families experience every day. Compared to that, jury duty’s pretty small potatoes.
I’ve been summoned a few times. I’ve always deferred due to being primary care provider of minor children. The funniest was when the state of CT called me TWICE after I moved to TX. I can understand the first time as it was right after we moved but I sent them a copy of my new TX driver’s license and a few months later they sent another notice…to my TX address.
Bureaucracy ![]()
Dh was called a couple of times and served on a two week murder trial. After that I really didn’t feel bad deferring jury duty until I don’t have little ones at home.
For a homeschooling mother, this presents a particular problem since there would be no one to care for or teach the children for that period of time during the school year. I have been exempted 3 times in two different states because I had a breastfeeding infant. I cringe when I think of what I would do if I had to line up a week’s worth of sitting/teaching for 6 children and pray I would be exempted until they are older. It’s not that I don’t want to do it. I assume my day will come… but please, Lord, not yet!
I got a summons a year or two ago, and sent the card back explaining that I am the primary caregiver for my son and don’t have anyone else to watch him. That seemed to do the trick. Years ago before I was married I was summoned a few times; only once did I have to show up at court, and was dismissed after a few minutes. I wouldn’t mind serving once my son is grown, but now I literally have no one else to watch him. Even if he were in school, I would need to be home in time to watch him after school.
I served on a 6 week trial when I was just about through the end of my first trimester with my first child. Given that we knew the trial would be long and that many people had some relation to the company being sued (on whether their airplane was defective and caused a crash), many potential jurors got out of serving. I had already scheduled my next OB appt for a day that court would not be in session so I couldn’t use an appt as an excuse. They didn’t even dismiss me though my husband had worked for the law firm handling the defense!
The experience was completely exhausting, as I had to travel via train then subway then shuttle bus to get to court and on the 2 afternoons/week that court got out early, I always went to work. Despite the fact that it was exhausting, it was a great experience. I appreciated being part of a jury comprised of thoughful individuals who took the role seriously and the court officer was very caring and always made sure I was comfortable. Obviously, now that I have children, I can’t imagine taking the time to serve and I think it is especially difficult to ask a nursing mother to serve.
I always encourage those who are able to serve to do so. It is an intellectually and interpersonally interesting experience and the system needs honest, thoughtful people to serve.
I think I’ve been called 3x in 20 years. I’ve been relieved of duty a couple of times while I was breastfeeding. I have no family nearby to watch children, and my husband has to work, so I don’t know how I could line up extended daily child care. I’m more than happy to do my duty, but my primary one right now is to my little ones, so if they can’t come with me, I can’t do it.
I have no idea what I would do if called to serve since I am a homeschooling mom with absolutely no relatives to take care of my kids My husband only gets vacation at Christmas and one week a year set by the company so he could not stay home. He might be able to call in sick one or two days but he tries hard not to take sick days even when he is sick. Hiring a nanny for a short term assignment like that would probably cost about $200 a day which we can’t afford. I am TOTALLY in favor of professional juries.
I just served last week. I went to jury selection, but wasn’t picked. The process was interesting, but I am glad I didn’t have to arrange more time away from work. In our state/county you are exempt from jury duty for 4 years after being summoned. The only exemption is federal court. They can call any time. So, if you are ever called up more often, you can say that you’ve served.
I was called once, about 25 years ago. It was for Federal Court, and I was selected, though as an alternate. I sat through the entire case, but then the judged deemed that the rest of jury was “intact” and it didn’t look like they’d need me for deliberations, so I was excused. I was single then, and it was no trouble with my employers at all, so not a problem. I have been summoned a couple times since then, but always had infants/pre-schoolers at home and so was excused. Still waiting for the ‘next’ call…whenever that might be.
In our state (or county - whoever makes the decisions here) does not care if you are breastfeeding an infant or are homeschooling. Without getting into all the sad details, I know both of these first hand. Thankfully all turned out ok. But it was very stressful.
I have never been called, which is too bad because I would’ve welcomed the interesting experience & chance to serve my community. I would be furious if I was required to serve now as a nursing mama. I’m sure it’d be the end of the nursing relationship with my toddler if I was (we don’t even own a pump or bottles!) and that’s a decision the government shouldn’t be able to make for any family. I really don’t understand why all the courts don’t leave moms of babies and toddlers alone for a few years.
About 4-5 months ago, I got my letter stating they would need me in May to serve. My 7th baby would be about 6 weeks at that time. I sent a letter back stating I would be unable to serve because of breastfeeding, unless they would allow me to bring my baby with! They sent a letter back saying I was dismissed at this time due to “hardship”!!!! Love it! Didn’t realize sustaining your baby is considered a hardship in some circles!
In my state (Massachusetts) no one is automatically excused. Since I’ve been here, a US Senator has served on a jury and a sitting Supreme Court Justice was called for jury duty - but the defense attorney excluded him. You may defer for up to 12 months. I do, to arrange a time when relatives can come in from out of town to watch the kids. They get the week off school though - watching 6 kids is hard enough, without trying to teach school. The last two times, I served in my 3rd trimester. The first time, they wanted to put me on a longer trial and I explained my in-laws could not stay that long, so they put me on a shorter (2 day) trial. In my experience, if you have made arrangements so you can serve a shorter trial, they are impressed and help you. But from hearing the court personnel talk, if you show up with a child because you couldn’t find anyone to watch it for one day with a year’s notice, they are NOT impressed.
I’ve never been called to serve, though I’ve always wanted to. I am a big proponent of representative juries. Here in Ontario, I am certain that you can be dismissed for compassionate reasons. My father was called two months after a near-fatal heart attack, and they had no problem excusing him. More recently, a close girlfriend was called. She is the single mother of a nursing child under two, and the trial looked to be one in which the jury would be cloistered. There was just no way she could, so she was excused.
I’ve been called 3 times in 50+ years. We are in a county of 10,000. My husband has been called about the same and once for federal jury. Sounds like every year is a bit much.
I’ve only been called once, but was dismissed pretty much upon entering the room.(maybe because my father is the head public defender for the entire county and as a result I know pretty much every lawyer, judge, clerk and police officer in the county) Perhaps, one day I’ll move a little farther way and have a chance to do my civic duty…
I’ve actually never been called for duty. A few years ago, though, my husband served as foreman on a jury for a sexual abuse case (a young girl was the victim). It was incredibly disturbing for him. I used to think I’d welcome the chance to serve, but after his experience, I’m hoping to continue to avoid it.
I’ve been called twice in the last ten years and both times was immediately excused because I had a young child (one time it was a nursing infant, the next it was a preschooler). I would have no problem serving when my children are older, but frankly I’d be a terrible juror right now if I were forced to be one because my concern would be for my babies (I currently have a 2 yo and a 1 yo) and not the trial. Too distracting!
As an attorney, I’ve always wanted to serve and see what happens inside the jury room. I’ve only been called twice. The first time I made it to voir dire (the jury selection pool), but was pointed out as an attorney and not chosen. The second time I never even made it that far. As frustrating as it would to rearrange my life and find care for my children, I take our obligation of public service seriously, both as an American and a Catholic.
In our state jury duty is every 3 years, not every year. I am grateful. I hate jury duty as I see our system as flawed. Anyone with enough money can wheedle their way out of taking responsibility it seems. I did get called for the Grand Jury once. I was a single working mother at the time and Iwas excused as I was sole care giver for my little ones.
The first time I ever received a jury duty summons was just after the moving truck loaded up our household belongings to move to another state. I sent the request back explaining the move (postmarked from our new hometown) and that was that. This past winter I received one in our current state and deferred until summer as I couldn’t ask someone to watch and school five children in March. So, it is looming for me at the end of July and I still need to figure out child care. That part stresses me out a lot. I would be happy to serve if I did not have young children. Interestingly, there are about 4 homeschooling mothers I know who have been summoned for jury duty this year. Coincidence or conspiracy?
In our county in Texas, we are eligible to serve every 6 months, however, it has been years since I have been called—watch I get a summons in today’s mail! I have been called 5 times and have actually served 2—one civil and one criminal, a murder. Those who feel our system is not working should be privileged to sit on a jury. The jurors I have known have been thoughtful and took their responsibility very seriously. I am a paralegal and feel it is imperative for all of us to serve. The jury system is a cornerstone of our justice system. It’s kinda like voting. Many complain about the system, but fail to vote. Can’t change things if you don’t participate.
In our state you can be drawn every 4 years…and I always am. I have been drawn for jury duty 5 times in 20 years. The last time I had a newborn and had to find care for him as they would not excuse me (breastfeeding or not). It is supposedly a “random” drawing but it doesn’t feel very random. I don’t know of anyone who has been drawn ONCE much less 5 times! I don’t mind doing my duty but I get a little irritated when my number comes up AGAIN and others never get drawn. It would seem a little more fair if every person was drawn the same # of times. : \
I wish that it would be more clear to people that if you get a driver’s license then you are obligated (unless certain circumstances apply) to do jury duty - at least in the state of California. I think it might also apply to having an ID card but I doubt it. So, many people I know gripe about having to do jury duty but they feel it a right to drive their car wherever they want. You need to do both and cannot take one without the other.
I have never served as a Juror. I always kinda wanted to, especially when I had a job I was tired of. However, I have been a clerk who worked in the courtroom during jury trials and I got to witness both a Civil and Criminal jury trial. I’ll take the Criminal jury trial if you please. Fortunately, in our county (Placer) you can be excused if you are the primary caregiver of whomever (child or elderly), the sole provider of a family ($15 per day doesn’t go far), or you have a prepaid vacation (I guess cancelling plane tickets is expensive). If you are unsure about what the accepted form of being excused is then don’t hesitate to call your local courthouse and ask. They should be able to inform you of what their rules are so you are not surprised when you are told you will be serving on a jury. Judges have the authority to put you in jail (as my dh was told by a judge) if you try to argue your way out of it.
Think of Jury duty as a break from life. You enter a complicated legal system that you rarely see and get to learn interesting things you never dreamed of. Law is fascinating and never ceases to change.
I was called up to serve last January. And, in the state of Indiana, being the primary caregiver of a two-year-old did not exempt me from duty, even when I explained that I know literally nobody within three hours (we’re recent transplants) who could care for my daughter. The woman I spoke with did, however, tell me she could schedule me for a one-day trial that are usually reserved for Fridays. She told me that it was unlikely that I would have to serve because there are very few one-day trials. She assigned me a Friday and told me to call at the beginning of that week to see if there was a trial scheduled for that day. Thankfully, there was not. Although, if I only had to serve for one day, it would have been feasible for my husband to take the day off to care for our daughter.
The ironic thing is that I’d been waiting and hoping since I was a little girl and my father had to serve jury duty that I would be called up to serve, too. All those years a professional single, and not until I’m pregnant and a SAHM in a state without family or friends in the area do I get called! Funny.
Personally, I think even bottle-feeding mothers should be excused. It’s one thing when someone has a job outside the home that pays their salary and benefits while they serve. It’s another thing for a stay-at-home mom who doesn’t have childcare. What would they do if the mom showed up with her kids because she couldn’t leave them alone?
I only had received notice and both times had requested the court moved closer to home. The first time I went I couldn’t be picked because I am totally biased when it comes to crimes. The second I was collecting unemployment so wouldn’t have gotten any money out of it so I was dismissed. Unemployment allows NO provisions for job searching requirement.
I fear I am due for another one any time now.
Post a Comment
By submitting this form, you give Faith And Family Magazine permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.




