Faith & Family Live!

Faith & Family Live is where everyday moms offer one another inspiration, support, and encouragement in Catholic living. Anyone grappling with the meaning of life or the cleaning of laundry is welcome here. Read the blog, check out our magazine, join our community, learn more about our mission, and come on in! READ MORE

Bloggers

Meet the Faith & Family bloggers. We invite you to join us in encouraging and helping the Faith & Family community grow in faith!

Danielle Bean

Danielle Bean
Danielle Bean, a mother of eight, is Editorial Director of Faith & Family. She is author of My Cup of Tea, Mom to Mom, Day to Day, and most recently Small Steps for Catholic Moms. Though she once struggled to separate her life and her work, the two …
Read My Posts

Rachel Balducci

Rachel Balducci
Rachel Balducci is married to Paul and they are the parents of five lively boys and one precious baby girl. She is the author of How Do You Tuck In A Superhero?, and is a newspaper columnist for the Diocese of Savannah, Georgia. For the past four years, she has …
Read My Posts

Lisa Hendey

Lisa Hendey
Lisa Hendey is the founder and editor of CatholicMom.com and the author of A Book of Saints for Catholic Moms and The Handbook for Catholic Moms. Lisa is also enjoys speaking around the country, is employed as webmaster for her parish web sites and spends time on various …
Read My Posts

Arwen Mosher

Arwen Mosher
Arwen Mosher lives in southeastern Michigan with her husband Bryan and their 4-year-old daughter, 2-year-old son, and twin boys born May 2011. She has a bachelor's degree in theology. She dreads laundry, craves sleep, loves to read novels and do logic puzzles, and can't live without tea. Her personal blog site …
Read My Posts

Rebecca Teti

Rebecca Teti
Rebecca Teti is married to Dennis and has four children (3 boys, 1 girl) who -- like yours no doubt -- are pious and kind, gorgeous, and can spin flax into gold. A Washington, DC, native, she converted to Catholicism while an undergrad at the U. Dallas, where she double-majored in …
Read My Posts

Robyn Lee

Robyn Lee
Robyn Lee is a 30-something, single lady, living in Connecticut in a small bungalow-style kit house built by her great uncle in the 1950s. She also conveniently lives next door to her sister, brother-in-law and six kids ... and two doors down are her parents. She received her undergraduate degree from …
Read My Posts

DariaSockey

DariaSockey
Daria Sockey is a freelance writer and veteran of the large family/homeschooling scene. She recently returned home from a three-year experiment in full time outside employment. (Hallelujah!) Daria authored several of the original Faith&Life Catechetical Series student texts (Ignatius Press), and is currently a Senior Writer for Faith&Family magazine. A latecomer …
Read My Posts

Guest Bloggers

Kate Lloyd

Kate Lloyd
Kate Lloyd is a rising senior, and a political science major at Thomas More College of Liberal Arts in New Hampshire. While not in school, she lives in Whitehall PA, with her mom, dad, five sisters and little brother. She needs someone to write a piece about how it's possible to …
Read My Posts

Lynn Wehner

Lynn Wehner
As a wife and mother, writer and speaker, Lynn Wehner challenges others to see the blessings that flow when we struggle to say "Yes" to God’s call. Control freak extraordinaire, she is adept at informing God of her brilliant plans and then wondering why the heck they never turn out that …
Read My Posts

Get our FREE Daily Digest

Add Faith & Family to iTunes

 

Letting God In

Coffee Talk: NFP

(Join each day’s Coffee Talk discussion: Mon: Parenting; Tues: Open Forum; Wed: NFP; Thu: Marriage; Fri: Education; Sat/Sun: Homemaking)

This weekly thread is a place where you can share your struggles, triumphs, links, resources, concerns, and questions about all things related to Natural Family Planning.

Please join the conversation!


Comments

Page 1 of 1 pages

 

After years of charting only mucus, I’ve started taking my temps this month. (I’m on day 9.) Most have been in the 97.1 range, but on days 6 and 7, I got 97.5 and 97.3. Now they’re back down. I’ve had a cold this week…could that explain the spike? Based on mucus and how early it is in my cycle, I think it’s highly unlikely that I ovulated.

 

Yes, having a mild illness can make your waking temps go up slightly for a couple days.

 

Does anyone know the Church’s teaching on using NFP to avoid pregnancy when you plan to adopt?  My last pregnancy and labor turned me off to having any more children naturally, and yet my husband and I still want to have a larger family.  We’ve always considered adoption a possibility, but somehow it feels wrong to avoid pregnancy when we plan on adopting.  There was nothing life-threatening about my pregnancies or deliveries, and both children have been healthy, but I just don’t think I can handle going through it again.  And I know there are so many children out there that need homes and the love of being a part of a family.  Am I being selfish?  Would we be going against Church teaching?

 

No easy answers here! Nothing helps more than prayer in decisions like these. I think the answer depends in large part on the motivation for adoption. Is it a real expression of love and self-giving? Or is the desire to have a large family coming from the feeling that large families are the approved thing in certain Catholic circles? What’s at the bottom of it all: fear or love?

Forgive me for being so blunt! I sincerely hope this helps. May God bless whatever you undertake.

 

Just wanted to encourage you that every pregnancy and birth is different, I’ve had 3 so far and can hardly even compare the births to each other!

 

Sorry to be so blunt, but as I understand it, as a Catholic, you can only put off pregnancy for a grave reason.  I don’t think fear of/distaste for pregnancy and birth would count.  And while adoption is an extremely admirable and charitable thing, I also don’t think we’re supposed to voluntarily replace having our own children with taking in other people’s.  However, I’m not a theologian; aside from telling you to pray sincerely about it, the best advice I can give you is to go talk to a solid, knowledgeable priest.
I’ll keep you and your decision-making in my prayers.

 

Dear Unsure,
Planning to adopt is such a beautiful thing to do.  As the other commenter mentioned, knowing the heart of the reason who you feel called to adopt is very important.  It could be, that God is placing it on your heart because he needs you to be parents to a very special child who is just waiting for your love, and to be a part of your family.  Only you and your spouse can know what God is calling you to.

My husband and I lost our first baby girl, fairly early in our pregnancy, but I was so distraught and heartbroken, I never thought we would be able to carry a child to term.  God has blessed us with three more babies in the past four years.  Our experiences with pregnancy, labor, and birth have all been both amazing and difficult.  I know pregnancy can be a very hard thing to handle, especially when you have other little people running around!  I guess I just wanted to say that that it is such an amazing gift that we are able to cary life inside of us!  The popular media’s view of pregnancy is so off-putting, like you only have to get through it, that their is no joy associated with pregnancy or labor.  I think that the greatest lie we’ve been told is that we cannot enjoy labor, that it will always be only pain, and that our bodies aren’t strong enough to endure labor.  After having my past two babies naturally,( thanks to the Bradley method of preparation for childbirth) I can honestly say that our labors and births are the moments in my life that I am most proud of, and the moment’s in which I felt most amazingly strong and alive.  Even now, I use the methods of dealing with physical pain to help me deal with stressful situations, with patience, and with calming my own children’s pain.  I certainly don’t mean to sound preachy, I just wanted to share with you that your pregnancies can be a great source of joy, but you have to be open to that as a real possibility.  If you truly feel God is calling you to not put off pregnancy even while going through the adoption process, maybe God has an amazing pregnancy and birth experience in store for you:)
May God Guide you on your journey:)
MNS

Great books to read on positive pregnancy and birth stories are Ina May’s Guide To Pregnancy and Birth, The Bradley Method of Natural Childbirth, and Birthing From Within.  These books were the real key to helping my husband and I change our way of viewing pregnancy and childbirth.  All the best!

 

Unsure,
This is a really difficult question and one I had not thought about until now. I am the proud mother of one son who was adopted, but we are unable to have biological children (barring a miracle). I agree with Lina that distaste of/ fear of pregnancy is probably not a good reason for postponing a pregnancy. However, if your life would be at risk with another pregnancy then you would be justified in using NFP to avoid pregnancy, and could with a clear conscience pursue adoption. You should discuss this with a good priest or Catholic ethicist.

Don’t think however, that adoption is necessarily easier than pregnancy/childbirth. It is different, and can be difficult. I don’t want to put people off adoption because it is a wonderful way to form a family. But don’t underestimate the effects of invasion of privacy, the waiting, the costs, the possibility that you may not be able to adopt an infant (if that is what you are thinking).

Having said that, I think that in the US you are able to adopt and have biological children at more or less the same time (though I would not recommend it, and new infant and a newly adopted child regardless of age, are both demanding).

I hope this is helpful.

May the Holy Spirit guide you in this decision.

 

I think it would be ok to use NFP to postpone pregnancy for a time during the process of adoption, IF you felt very strongly called to adopt a child. Adoption is an act of compassion and mercy and I think it is fine sometimes to postpone pregnancy when God is calling you to give a demanding gift of yourself that is not compatible with pregnancy (for you).

On the other hand, I think that if your primary reason for wanting to adopt is fear of childbirth, you need to really pray and think about that. Adoptive children deserve and need to be desired for their own sake, not as a way to assuage your conscience about being ‘open to life’ while avoiding childbearing. Not that this is necessarily what you’re doing, but your post does make it sound that way!!

Perhaps as well you need to consider why you are afraid of pregnancy, whether there is something that could be changed to improve your pregnancy experience, or whether there is something deeper at the root of that fear. I think most of us find pregnancy uncomfortable and arduous - it certainly involves a lot of dying to self! - but that the end is worth the process. There are factors that can make it harder/scarier…only in retrospect, for example, have I realized that I should probably have sought treatment for anxiety attacks during my pregnancies - but those are things that can be prepared for.

May the Spirit give you discernment, wisdom and peace as you pray through this decision!

 

Of course it is acceptable in God’s eyes to avoid a pregnancy to adopt.
I think it is extremely fundamentalist to say otherwise.  I am saddened by the train of thought out there in the Catholic community.  God does have a plan for the millions of orphans in the world to be raised in a family and I think He is juts hoping some hearts would be open to it.  Be open to life is a very broad term.  Listen to your heart and seek wise counsel.

 

Beth could you explain why its ok to avoid preg. to adopt?  Each act of intercourse is called to be open to life, so if a couple was capable of having children, desired more children, but deliberately did not desire to bear more children themselves, isn’t that using NFP with a contraceptive mentality?

sure, adoption is great and could also be part of growing a family, but how is deliberately not having more children (but planning on continuing to have sex) just to have more children a different way morally acceptable?

 

Lina,

I do not think you can determine for another couple the morality of this.  The Church does not list just reasons to avoid of pregnancy, that is left to the couple to decide with God.  If a couple decides they graciously want to welcome an orphan into their home and in orer to do that they need to avoid pregnancy then the God I know says go for it!!

I find such a militant and fundamentalist attitude in the Catholic Church these days that it is very difficult to hear.

Are you really encouraging other Catholics not to consider adoption?  Because this is a sin?  To avoid conception to welcome an orphan?  What responsibility to we have to the orphans of the world?

 

MR,

I don’t know how all sympto-thermal methods work, only CCL’s, but what you’re looking for is a “sustained” thermal shift of 3 or more days at or above the High Temp. Level, which is 0.4 degrees above your Low Temp. Level.  If you haven’t had something sustained, cross-checked by a drying up of mucus, then I would say you have not ovulated.  It is common to have a sort of up and down pattern (or non-pattern!) before the thermal shift, but the shift itself will account for what I listed above.  Obviously, this is a generalization of method rules, so don’t take my word as gospel, but that is generally how it is supposed to work.

 

Has anyone else ever had brown spotting/staining during early pregnancy?  I am at 6 1/2 weeks right now, and last night noticed this discharge (change from normal yellow), with some minor brownish discharge this morning.  The doctor had said when I scheduled my first appointment (in two weeks) to call if there was bright red bleeding or cramps, so I wasn’t sure if I should be concerned at this at all—I feel fine otherwise.  My first pregnancy was completely normal and we just conceived again on our first attempt.  Is this something worth checking on, or not worry about at this point?

 

Kim, I have had early spotting in 4 of my 5 pregnancies.  If there is no cramping associated with the spotting, ‘try’ not to worry.  It may be implantation bleeding.  However, if the spotting changes color (darker red) and cramping, consult your doctor right away.  (Just a side note, my first pregnancy ended in a miscarriage at 6 wks, the other 3 went fine and I’m currently on my 5th pregnancy…wk 26).

 

Yes! My first pregnancy I had no spotting but my second and third (which I am currently pregnant with- 13 weeks) I HAVE had spotting.  Of course it always can be a sign of something wrong, but it also can be completely normal.  Of course there is often implantation spotting (but you are a bit late for that). But the last two I got spotting around week 12 and then almost every month.  It was a totally healthy pregnancy and she is a beautiful baby girl (17 months now).  I would say, it is fine as long as the bleeding doesn’t increase to more than a tablespoon or turn into heavier bleeding.  Also, watch for cramping. These could be signs it is more serious.  Even with just a bit of spotting, tell your doc. about it next visit, but try not to worry in the meantime.  When this happened with my first pregnancy I was freaked out, but the more people I told the more I found out how normal it is.  I think it is probably a hormonal thing (as most things are!).  It also can be caused by intercourse (as your cervix has more blood and is sensitive).  For me though it was almost like mini periods- which seems totally weird I know. Also, I have morning sickness, and so when I would have spotting and would still feel sick, I knew the baby was probably ok cause my hormones were still strong.  Also, later in the pregnancy when I had it I would still feel baby kick, and know he/she was ok. I hope this helps, and congratulations!

 

Thank you so much—that really helps me feel better!  My husband and I were together on Sunday night so that could be a common explanation based on what you said too.  Things are slow at work today so it was hard to keep my mind free from concern, but nothing appears to have changed for the worse and I still feel fine so I think it’s all right.  Just saying a few prayers smile  Congratulations to both of you on your pregnancies too!

 

I would agree with Theresa and Kim but as a doctor who does ob I would want you to call and let me know about the spotting—your doc may or may not want to see you but it is never a bad idea just to let him/her know.

 

Has anyone dealt with or know what very scant mucus means?  Any knowledge is appreciated and welcomed!

 

Just asking for you to send some prayers to the Blessed Mother and Saint Anne on my behalf. We are trying to conceive and the time is ripe. I should be ovulating today or tomorrow and we so desire to have another baby!

 

I’ll pray for you! Please do the same for me next month (not happening this month). Don’t you love these happy days! grin

 

Response to Lina: 

I had 5 children back-to-back and I admit that a fear of the pain and suffering of pregnancy is one of the big stumbling blocks I have when considering more children.

It is very very difficult to be a loving wife and mother, and to successfully run a household, when one is very ill from pregnancy.  Also…labor can be much harder for some mothers than for others.

I would not discount the pains of pregnancy and labor as a valid reason to practice NFP.

 

Paige, I have a similar experience to yours, and I agree with you. What I see in the beauty of NFP is that you are not making a “permanent” decision—you are making a decision for this month, right now, at this time in your life. Furthermore, you are making the decision and still leaving room for God to work—by not harming your body or using something foreign to the body to interfere with God’s work. And the way a couple feels this month may very well change next month. We all need to remember too that what may be “grave” for one couple may not be “grave” for another couple, as well as what might be grave this month, might not be as severe next month. It is for each couple to prayerfully decide, and to accept God’s will in the situation.

 

just wanted to chime in - there are two Linas on here smile  me and the one to whom people are talking.

that being said, i will say that I agree with Mary Therese:

We all need to remember too that what may be “grave” for one couple may not be “grave” for another couple, as well as what might be grave this month, might not be as severe next month.

i think this reason would definitely constitute a reason to avoid during NFP, in that women need time to recover, physically, mentally and emotionally pregnancy and childbirth.  but part of NFP is discerning God’s call for us each time we are fertile.

and i fear closing ourselves off to that call permanently is an improper use of NFP.

 

Hi, other Lina!
I agree that grave reasons come and go depending on time and circumstances.  However, I spoke so bluntly before mainly because Unsure said that her pregnancies and births had not been life-threatening, nor did she mention any other problems beside an apparent dislike for the whole process of pregnancy and birth.  I know some women feel great while pregnant and others definitely don’t; but perhaps pregnancy should be accepted as a cross, if we can’t enjoy it?
Unsure didn’t say if her babies were born very close together (I’m not going to tell any woman that she has to have a baby every year - that’s not good for the mother OR the children), or if her most recent baby was still only a few months old, or if she’d had or was recovering from post-partum depression, etc.  Obviously prudence is a large part of the decision whether to use NFP or not.
My main beef is with women who choose to use NFP as a kind of “Catholic birth control” - just because you’re not on the Pill or using other contraceptives doesn’t mean it’s OK to use NFP all the time or without good cause.  That is not how it is meant to be used.

 

other Lina - i can’t believe you spell your name properly!  i’ve never met another Lina (besides the woman i’m named for, my g.g. grandmother who actually died before i was born) who spells it right! smile

who are you?  where are you? we should be friends :-p

lol, anyways, i do agree with you as well - “catholic BC” isn’t what NFP is all about - its about discerning God’s call each and every month.


Post a Comment

By submitting this form, you give Faith And Family Magazine permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.

Name:

Email:

Website:

I am commenting on the one originally posted by the author

Write your comment:

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


     

Remember my personal information.

Notify me of follow-up comments.