I have friends of all different political stripes. The hardest thing for me to deal with is my pro-abortion relatives. It breaks my heart and angers me that people in my family give money to Planned Parenthood, and deny the humanity of the unborn.
Why Can't We Be Friends?
Posted by Rebecca Teti in Reviews on Friday, April 08, 2011 3:00 PM
“I can’t believe my best friend is a Republican” writes a pro-abortion liberal about her improbable friendship with a pro-life conservative.
Sometimes—often—their positions mutually infuriate each other, and yet:
We need friends who differ from us. It’s easy to watch Republican extremism and think, “Wow, they’re crazy.” But when someone is sitting face to face with us, when someone we admire and respect is telling us they believe differently, it is at this fine point that we find nuance, and we begin to understand exactly how we got to this point in history. We lose something critical when we surround ourselves with people who agree with us all the time. We lose out on the wisdom of seeing the other side.
This liberal woman admires her conservative friend. Through her, she’s come to see that being challenged doesn’t weaken us, it strengthens us:
Janet’s willingness to associate with so many liberal friends—though I know she seeks refuge in chat rooms and magazines that share her beliefs—makes her a better and more interesting person. She has her beliefs challenged constantly. She is more well-read and educated in her politics than most of the liberals I know. Too many liberals I know are lazy, they have a belief system that consists of making fun of Glenn Beck and watching “The Daily Show.” Shouldn’t their beliefs be challenged, too?
Then she comes to a point I’ve been thinking a lot about lately:
This is a democracy, after all. Isn’t it worth understanding a bit more about why approximately half the country votes differently than we do?
The author asks an important question (and of course if her friend had written this, all the particulars would be reversed):
Isn’t it important that we understand why people—good and legitimate Americans, whose votes count as much as ours—like Sarah Palin? Isn’t it crucial we figure out why any woman would want to defund Planned Parenthood, if only so we could then address the argument? Nobody benefits from sitting in a room, agreeing with everyone else.
Naturally, I’m on the pro-life side—and I’m fairly confident if that conversation were actually allowed to take place, we’d—eventually—have a convert to the pro-life cause.
But I think the larger point—that regardless of where we fall on the political spectrum, it’s pretty lazy to assume that fully half the country is merely stupid or base, and we owe it to ourselves to up our game, conversation-wise—is well-observed.
As she says, this is a democracy. Self-government depends upon citizens being self-governing in two ways: governing their own persons in the sense of self-restraint; and maintaining dialogue with fellow citizens about how best to effect the common good. If we simply stop trying to understand and trust each other, we won’t remain free.
In my next post I’ll address Pope Benedict XVI’s take on civil dialogue, but for now, I like the author’s last line about her political-opposite friend:
I can’t help it. I love her.
Do you have friends on the opposite side of the political spectrum? How do you navigate your disagreements?
Comments
Page 1 of 1 pages
One of my closest friends is a card carrying, politically active, Obama-fan, tree-hugging, fallen away Catholic, atheist, liberal. She refers to me as her BCF. Best.Conservative.Friend.
We rarely discuss politics. We tend to stay where we have common ground. Homeschooling, large family dynamics (she has 5, I have 9 ), asperger’s and autism (we each have an Aspergian teenage boy) and other things like that. I’m sure we would be a lot closer if I was a liberal atheist or she a conservative Catholic but for now, we are what we are. We keep each other honest in our political discourse. Our friendship reminds each of us that there are real people behind the labels not just Us and Them.
I have thought of writing a blog post or essay about whether or not we should only seek companions that are “just like us” and is that even really possible.
Even if I think I have found someone ‘just like me’, they aren’t. No one holds exactly the same opinions and beliefs as I do, even my husband.
Hi,
When I was in college I had a roommate who was this extremely Catholic, pro-life, conservative right-wing nut. I was the liberal, pro-choice atheist. We became good friends despite our differences. She always showed a lot of respect for my ideas and we had many heated debates. Fast forward ten years and I am now a pro-life conservative who has become much closer to God. I often think back to our debates and the mutual respect we had for each other. She taught me a lot and I thank her for it. If we had both written each other off I might never be where I am today. I am sure at the time she prayed for me, and I believe it worked!
I meet so many peole because we are constantly moving due to being a military family. Thus, we stay connected through Facebook. We all enjoy posting our political thoughts/beliefs and even questions on our profiles. Then others reply. It’s fun and people seem to say what they really want to say because they are not face to face. In addition, it’s easy to link articles, etc. and put up when debating. Sometimes it can get heated, but never mean. I truly learn a lot about different view points, especially right now with the gov’t possibly shutting down.
My children, my mother, and most of my childhood friends and professional colleagues don’t understand why I want to de-fund PP. It is interesting to me because I am on the ‘liberal’ end of the spectrum on issues like home birth and midwifery (although to me I am a true conservative there as well!) and on the ‘conservative’ end of issues like same sex relationships and family planning options. I think the most important thing we can do is to listen first and only speak words that are sweet and tender.
I completely agree, Rebecca! I feel very fortunate to have family and friends all across the political spectrum. I love being reminded how often I can learn something from someone with a viewpoint different from my own.
I also wanted to add that I think this applies to different kinds of Catholics too. I think it can be really easy and comfortable to associate with other Catholics who share our prayer and worship preferences, our politics, our schooling choices, etc. But, I’m always pleasantly surprised by how much I learn from Catholics that seem really different from me on the surface. It’s nice to be reminded how much we share, instead of focusing on differences so much.
I have always had Catholic friends of radically different beliefs from a gay man to my cafeteria Catholic neighbors. Strangely, I get along better with them than the conservative evangelicals I know through homeschooling or pro-life work who supposedly share more of my beliefs. One thing I try to do now to get to know people with different beliefs is when meeting new people I don’t let on right away my beliefs but try to develop a rapport and trust first so I don’t scare them off.
My family covers the full spectrum, politically and religiously. Our annual Christmas yankee swap often includes both Hillary Clinton and Rush Limbaugh books, with the hope of having the most opposite in belief end up with the book most anathema to them.
I try not to feel threatened by my (mostly) liberal friends. I often think about GK Chesterton and William F. Buckley who had good friends who were political opposites of themselves. It’s ok to disagree. Besides, I realized a long time ago, that most of my liberal friends don’t read. They watch TV and listen to NPR. That’s pretty much it. So now I think of them more as just uninformed.
Post a Comment
By submitting this form, you give Faith And Family Magazine permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.




